The salienceagenda meaningspin model of persuasion. Jul 15, 2019 the use of dualprocess models in sociologyincluding the two distinct bodies of work re viewed in this chapterhas not been without criticism. The dual processes, or system 1 and system 2, work together by enabling a clinician to think both fast and slow when reasoning through a patients presentation system 1 is intuitive, efficient, and based. However, they do not necessarily think deeply or carefully, because to do so requires considerable cognitive effort. Persuasion, social influence, and compliance gaining 4th. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. A persuasion theory saying that change in attitude can result from strategies for processing attitude relevant information involving a high or low degree o. Their theory is called the elaboration likelihood model of persuasion. Elaboration likelihood model, judgment and decision making. Author lillian beeson offers a balance of classic rhetorical theories and contemporary socialscience approaches. Persuasion is an active, intentional attempt to change nonverifiable evaluations, feeling, values, norms, and related behaviors. Dual process models in attitude change and persuasion dual processing is probably best known to marketing scholars in the context of persuasion and attitude change studies, frequently used in advertising research.
It is simply the reaction of the destination back to the source, direct andor indirect. Pdf dual process theories divide the realm of mental processes into two general categories depending on. In psychology, a dual process theory provides an account of how thought can arise in two different ways, or as a result of two different processes. Other books are general reference works that cover theory and research in attitudes and persuasion. The two models differ little, but they have a lot in common as you can see.
Mar 05, 2010 there is also a discussion of the unimodel of persuasion, an alternative to dual process models. Identify and explain the major tenets of persuasion and framing theory. Context is considered as a very significant component as it decides the given communication process and fixes all the above said 7 components. It covers persuasion from both points of view helping consumers to make better buys and salespeople to. Chapter 14 dual process th eories bertram gawronski. From political speeches to television commercials to war propaganda, it can effectively mobilize political action, influence the public, and market products. Second, the chapter critically discusses the theories implications for human rationality, particularly their equation of heuristic processing with irrationality. Weve also added new material on the goalsplansaction model gpa of compliance gaining, cultivation theory, and the phenomenon known as psychological. Written primarily for researchers and graduate students, its coverage of the issues in attitudebehavior consistency is comprehensive and thoughtful. Feedback is the loop of making a twoway communication process related to the response to the message.
Concurrently, with the rise of mass media and the pervasiveness. The dual process models of persuasion explain how attitude change happens by linking persuasion to social cognition. This paper integrates duality models from the perspective of consumer psychology by identifying three relevant theoretical strands. With this in mind, we provide an overview of research on persuasion. The other major model is called the heuristicsystematic model, which shares much in common with the elm. The concept of attitude has occupied a central place in both social psychology allport 1935 and. Persuasive effects of fictional narratives 1 running head. The dynamics of persuasion has been a staple resource for teaching persuasion for nearly two decades. Techniques such as psychophysiological interaction ppi analysis could be. Persuasion and compliance gaining more discerning consumer of persuasive messages, especially unscrupulous forms of influence. Dualprocess theories, which highlight both automatic and controlled routes to. When, however, the same stuffed replica carried inside it a small recorder that played the cheepcheep sound of baby turkeys, the mother not only accepted the oncoming polecat but gathered it under. The rational model of persuasion is based on the idea that people behave in predictable ways based on their beliefs and values.
The dual process theory has been adapted from the psychology literature to describe how clinicians think when reasoning through a patients case 1. Dual process and dual system theories in both cognitive and social psychology have been subjected to a number of recently published criticisms. Persuasion is a process by which people use messages to influence others. Eagly and chaiken 1993 has long been the goto text for all information related to attitudes. Verbalized explicit processes or attitudes and actions may change with persuasion. Examples include petty and cacioppos elaboration likelihood model explained below and chaikens heuristic systematic model.
Persuasion attempts to change minds or get people to act. They have integrated and accounted for a significant number of previous persuasion phenomena and guided contemporary research in the field. Persuasion, social influence, and compliance gaining, third edition, looks at persuasion from a broadbased perspective, encompassing the full scope of persuasion found in everyday life. In persuasion, for instance, the development of two dual process theories the elaboration likelihood model and the heuristicsystematic model allowed researchers to organize complex findings in the field of attitudes and attitude change and explain why certain variables sometimes lead to attitude change and sometimes do not. However, they have been attacked as a category, incorrectly assuming there is a generic version that applies to all.
The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 320 pages and is available in paperback format. By including works from aristotle to kenneth burke, persuasion. Researchers, graduate students, and advanced undergraduates have gained a valuable resource for understanding how dual process theories have been used to clarify our understanding of phenomena in many areas, including attitudes, person perception. The peripheral mode processes persuasive communications based on superficial, messageirrelevant cues such as communicator, context, or format. An evaluation of dualprocess theories of reasoning. In social psychology, dualprocess models began in the area of attitude change and persuasion with the. Persuasion and social influence psychological sciences.
The elaboration likelihood model cacioppo and petty describes the objectappraisal understanding and evaluating function of attitudes, but depicts two modes, depending on motivation and capacity. Identify elements of persuasion theory for which empirical support has been found. Historically, there have been two major programs of attitude change research in social psychology, one a learning theory approach associated with carl hovland, the second a cognitive consistency approach associated with gestalt psychology and the research of fritz. Two important aspects have to be considered in this task. These models distinguish between qualitatively different modes of information processing in making decisions and solving problems e. Instead of specifying the effects of particular variables, they focus on the process of persuasion. Dissonance theory an overview sciencedirect topics. The psychology of persuasion demonstrates how to construct persuasive messages. Six scientifically validated principles of persuasion that provide for small practical, often costless changes that can lead to big differences in your ability to influence and persuade others in an entirely ethical way. Explaining theories of persuasion s ince the mid1930s when dale carnegie first published his bestselling book how to win friends and influence people, the notion of how to persuade others has been both a popular and profitable subject.
Instead of specifying the effects of particular variables, they focus on the. Psychology definition of dual process models of persuasion. Theory and applications provides a comprehensive introduction to persuasion. Theories of public relations uf college of journalism. Dual process theory definition psychology glossary. Two significant dual process models of attitude change were offered by petty and cacioppo 1984 and chaiken and eagly 1983.
The contemporary dual process models of persuasion address the importance of ability and motivation to elaboration, and the valence of recipients thinking about persuasive messages. Pdf dual process theories divide the realm of mental processes into two general categories depending on whether they operate automatically or in a. Social psychology chap 5 attitude psychology persuasion. First, under some conditions positive mood seems to facilitate careful processing of goalrelevant information, even negative information. According to these models, persuasion may occur after either intense scrutiny or extremely superficial thinking. Linn 8 looking ahead as a technique to reduce resistance to persuasive attempts 149 steven j. There is also a discussion of the unimodel of persuasion, an alternative to dual process models. We learn that the elliots are a respected, titled, landowning family. A dual process model of impression formation download ebook. In addition, there may be meaningful differences in the processes that.
Rethinking the role of positive affect in selfregulation. This applies to so many facets of life, but lets take one decision everyone has to make at some point. Dual system and dual process views of the human mind have contrasted automatic, fast, and nonconscious with controlled, slow, and conscious thinking. The dual process theory is a cognitive psychology theory that explains the different levels of information processing in individuals. As you can imagine, the source of the persuasive communication and the message itself are important factors in the persuasion. After a detailed illustration of the workings of the elm, the authors summarize the criticisms of the model that.
Dualprocess theory of supportive message outcomes the. This volume assembles leading researchers to provide indepth discussions of a key theoretical construct in cognitive and social psychology. Dec 31, 20 children are important targets of advertising campaigns from companies. Lady elliot, sir walters wife died fourtee n years ago and left him with three daughters.
His 35 years of rigorous, evidencebased research, along with a. The main characters of this business, non fiction story are. While persuasion typically uses information, the emphasis in a persuasive message is on influencing the receiver rather than merely providing information and letting the receiver make up hisher own mind. Beliefs and values are based on what the person knows about the world. The dual process models of persuasion look at effort involved. It teaches how to tell what the other person is thinking, why he thinks it, and how to change what he thinks. As described earlier, time has been used by many researchers of dual. It compares the general characteristics of dual process models in social psychology with similar models in other areas of psychology, and discusses implications of this comparison for several conceptual issues.
A dualstep and dualprocess model of advertising effects. Two routes to change factors that influence a persons motivation to process a message deeply. Elaboration implies critical attention to major points of an argument, whereas transportation is an immersion into a text. It is important to distinguish the findings in the three studies reported in this paper from previous work on time in the context of dualprocess models of attitude change e. In an experiment designed to test this prediction, 81. Persuasion opens with a brief history of the elliot family as recorded in sir walter elliots favorite book, the baronetcy.
Abstract study of attitudes and persuasion remains a defining characteristic of. Since the early 1980s, the dual process models of persuasion have dominated the persuasion landscape. Written in a clear and accessible style that assumes no special technical background in research methods, the third edition has been thoroughly revised to reflect developments in persuasion studies. The best books for teaching persuasive writing 1 eat your peas by kes gray. The first edition of the novel was published in 1984, and was written by robert b. Linked to empirical research, this text takes students from persuasion theory to qualified conclusions about the operation of persuasion in realworld settings and examines persuasion from a social science. Click download or read online button to get a dual process model of impression formation book now.
By the turn of the century, dual process models had become so popular in social psychology that an entire book was. Request pdf dual process models of persuasion the dual process models. Media argumentation by douglas walton cambridge core. Jan 05, 2017 dualprocess models of persuasion according to petty and cacioppos elaborationlikelihood model elm, when people receive a persuasive message they think about the arguments it makes. Dual process theories are a group of theories in social, personality, and cognitive. Dual process theories in social psychology iresearchnet. Dual process models of persuasion flashcards quizlet.
Dual process models are very common in the study of social psychological variables, such as attitude change. For instance, when a person looks at a book on a table, he or she senses both. First, advertising affects judgements and behaviour not only during ad exposure. Elab oration implies critical attention to major points of an argument, whereas transportation is an immersion into a text. Heuristicsystematic model of persuasion definition the heuristicsystematic model is a theory of persuasion that suggests attitudes can change in two fundamentally different ways. More recently, dual process theories of attitude change point to two different. Public relations and persuasion media ethics 10th edition. The salience agenda meaningspin model of persuasion explained for over 35 years there has been an academic fight on the relationship between rhetoric and situations.
Dualprocess models of information processing springerlink. They are the secrets from the science of persuasion. Lloyd bitzer, author of the 1968 article the rhetorical situation, offers a perspective that virtually makes rhetoric an unimportant study. The two most prominent dual process models are the elaboration likelihood model and the heuristic systematic model. Dual process theory explanation and examples conceptually. Dual process theory an overview sciencedirect topics. This article evaluates the arguments and the evidence. Motives in persuasion also have been investigated in research on attitude functions and cognitive dissonance theory. Perloff speaks to students in a style that is engaging and informational, explaining key theories and research as well as providing timely and relevant examples. Often, the two processes consist of an implicit automatic, unconscious process and an explicit controlled, conscious process.
It is important to distinguish the findings in the three studies reported in this paper from previous work on time in the context of dual process models of attitude change e. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. In psychology, a dual process theory provides an account of how thought can arise in two. However, children have been found to be particularly vulnerable to negative effects of advertising, and protecting children from these effects is an important task of consumer policy. It shares with constructivism a focus on explaining individual variability in communication skills and concentrates this focus by explaining the antecedents and consequences of message processing in the domain of supportive communication. Early dual process theories were proposed by the philosopher and psychologist william james and has been. Dual process models of persuasion xu major reference. Influence, the classic book on persuasion, explains the psychology of why people say yes and how to apply these understandings. One possibility from dual process models of persuasion is that some behavioral changes are ephemeral because the underlying attitudes that support the changes are weak e.
Dual process models of persuasion request pdf researchgate. In persuasion, it considers the cognitive and affective mechanisms underlying attitude change, especially dualmode processing models, recipi. Heuristicsystematic model of persuasion iresearchnet. Compared with phenomenonspecifi c and generalized dual process theories, formalized models have a unique advantage, in that they provide mathematical implementations that allow researchers to quantify the relative contributions of the proposed processes to a given task. Persuasion is the process of trying to influence someones beliefs or behaviors to evoke change the rational model of persuasion is based on the assumption that people behave in line with their. The systems are identified as having functionally distinct roles, differ according to the type of information encoded, vary according to the level of expressible knowledge, and result in different responses. One way is through systematic processing, whereby people think carefully about any available information when forming an opinion to determine whether the information is accurate or valid. The elaboration likelihood model is one of the two dual processing models of persuasion. Need for cognition the tendency to enjoy and engage in deliberate thought. Dual process models of persuasion xu major reference works.
Contrary to general dual process models of persuasion, models of persuasion through fiction also imply that persuasive effects of fictional narratives are persistent and even increase over time absolute sleeper effect. Personal relevance of the topic does it matter to you. The dualprocess theory of supportive message outcomes is a social cognitive theory firmly rooted in constructivism. Does advertising literacy mediate the effects of advertising. Theory and research, third edition is a comprehensive overview of socialscientific theory and research on persuasion. Our starting point is to note that the pattern of findings in the literature is consistent with dual process models of persuasion. Attitudes contents attitude formation mere exposure associative learning selfperception functional approach attitudes and behaviour determinants of the attitudebehavior relationship the theory of planned behavior reasoned action versus spontaneity attitude change cognitive dissonance persuasion dual process models of persuasion. Robert cialdini is the seminal expert in the rapidly expanding field of influence and persuasion. It is used in many different psychological fields including social, cognitive, and clinical psychology. Media argumentation is a powerful force in our lives. It compares the general characteristics of dualprocess models in social psychology with similar models in other areas of psychology, and discusses implications of this comparison for several conceptual issues. The decision can be broken down into parts, some are more appropriate for system 1 reasoning, and some are appropriate for using your system 2.
271 549 905 934 1465 620 1200 1492 356 252 10 1271 1389 1497 1489 866 579 1162 219 1354 829 1004 363 885 801 1291 547 418 441 816 155 1398 79 919